I don't think you're weird at all, Geanina!!!IMO, I think it just comes down to "chemistry." I may really enjoy a book, but my personal keepers always seem to be the ones that have a hero & heroine with whom, for whatever reason, I really connect (aka...chemistry). Kinda like dating...on paper someone may have all the qualities you're looking for, and thus "should" be a good match and perfect for you, but if there is no chemistry, it's not going to happen.
So, while I love, love, love all of SEP's books, my reader chemistry with Heath and Annabelle are the main reason why Match Me is my favorite SEP book (well...Heath & Annabelle and their AMAZINGLY funny and heartfelt story
)
LisaA in Washington state