Welcome to the Susan Elizabeth Phillips Bulletin Board

All good-hearted readers welcome.

Subject: "What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene"     Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy    
Conferences OLDER BOOKS DISCUSSION Topic #173
Reading Topic #173, reply 1
hopeful soul
Member since Nov-23-05
11096 posts
Aug-05-07, 06:56 PM (CST)
Click to EMail hopeful%20soul Click to send private message to hopeful%20soul Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
1. "RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene"
In response to message #0
 
   This is a hard one...

From the top of my head, I'll have to say my fav scene is at the end of Heaven, Texas, the confrontation between Way and Bobby-Tom, followed by Bobby-Tom's realization of what he was doing to his mother by not giving his blessing. However, the scene that gets me all tense, and worried like is when Way makes Suzie play his companion, and the whole bathtub scene. I recently heard Anna Field's read it, and wow, I was literally holding my breath waiting for the shoe to drop. I think what gets me is that it really deals with the issues of widowhood. I can't imagine spending a life-time loving somebody, and then learning to move on...

My other favourite scene is from THOM, with Kevin and the baseball game, and how he wondered if his daughter would have been like Hannah; actually any scene with Kevin thinking about Sarah makes me cry. It makes parenting sound so magical...loving someone so intensely, yet not really knowing them...

There are so many scenes, it's so hard to narrow it down...

Oh, the other one that really got to me was with Riley, Jack, and Dean, and the whole suicide thing. WOW! That whole thing hit too close to home for me, and I think SEP wrote it all out so beautifully. I mean, how does one react to a child's talk about death and suicide, when the child really doesn't understand what she is talking about, or understand the gravity of it all.

- Amal


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
 What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene [View All] redsox04 Aug-05-07 TOP
  RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene hopeful soul Aug-05-07 1
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Anisa Aug-05-07 2
      RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Anisa Aug-05-07 4
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene br Aug-05-07 3
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene ca_gt Aug-06-07 5
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene luci_0775 Aug-07-07 6
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Mel113 Aug-07-07 7
      RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene dlehker Aug-07-07 8
          RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Mel113 Aug-07-07 9
              RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Anisa Aug-07-07 10
                  RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Mel113 Aug-07-07 11
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene halibev Aug-17-07 12
      RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene redsox04 Aug-18-07 13
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene krg Aug-19-07 14
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Anisa Aug-20-07 15
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Celia B Aug-26-07 16
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene maya Aug-26-07 17
      RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Mel113 Aug-26-07 18
          RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene *** SPOILERS * dreamweaver May-30-08 19
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene bandit May-31-08 20
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene scrubsgh Jun-03-08 21
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene I love KT Jun-03-08 22
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Linda in PA Jun-05-08 23
      RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene bijoux Jun-06-08 24
      RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Cetacea Jun-06-08 26
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Mezzo Jun-06-08 25
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Jamie P Jul-09-08 27
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene Laura Z Jul-09-08 28
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene ***SPOILERS*** dmummey Aug-08-08 29
   RE: What is your ALL TIME Favorite Scene enorden07 Jun-26-10 30


Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic